Creative Yarn Source Reviews

Creative Yarn Source has an overall rating of 1.4 based on 22 reviews. Customer feedback on Creative Yarn Source is mixed.

1.4/5.0

22 reviews

5 Stars

0

4 Stars

2

3 Stars

1

2 Stars

1

1 Star

18

All Creative Yarn Source Reviews (22)
hello_leslie748
June 01, 2026
"My packaging arrived beat up"
My yarn showed up in a crushed box, and the bag inside was split open too. I know shipping can be rough sometimes, but this felt like it wasn’t protected very well at all. For something like yarn, I really expect it to arrive clean and neatly packed, so I was disappointed with how careless the packaging looked.
edna_Mitchell95
May 29, 2026
"International shipping was really slow"
I ordered a few yarns to Germany, and the shipping took way longer than I expected. Like I said, I knew it was coming from overseas, so I wasn’t expecting it overnight, but the tracking barely updated for days and I had no clue where my package actually was.
The yarn was totally fine once it finally arrived, so no complaints there. But like I said, the waiting and lack of clear shipping info made it frustrating, and I’m not sure I’d order internationally again.
teresahenderson2670
May 26, 2026
"Not really worth the price"
The prices felt high for what I ended up getting. I was expecting a lot more for the money, so it was disappointing. I feel like an apology would be fair here because the experience just didn’t match the cost.
Deidra_mortenson97
May 15, 2026
"I was browsing yarn on Creative Yarn Source..."
I was browsing yarn on Creative Yarn Source the site looks nice at first. The pages are clean enough, and I liked some of the yarn options, but the descriptions kind of lost me. They had information, but not really the details I actually needed, like clear yarn weight, texture, or what kinds of projects it would be best for. At the same time, maybe someone more experienced could figure it out just fine, but I didn’t want to sit there guessing. Buying yarn online is already a little tricky, so I was hoping for quick, simple details. I ended up liking the look of a few products but still leaving the site more confused than when I started
eileen-Kenny
May 07, 2026
"Promo code didn’t even work"
I saw a discount code listed on the site, so I figured I was getting a deal, but then it just wouldn’t apply at checkout. No explanation, no clear reason, nothing. The total ended up being way higher than I expected, and honestly… make it make sense. It felt like I wasted my time.
elsa.Fields
April 21, 2026
"I had an issue with my..."
I had an issue with my yarn order and had to email them twice about it. They did end up sorting it out and sent the missing item, which I appreciated. Not sure how to explain it, but the whole thing felt a little slower than it probably needed to be. Overall, I’m glad it got fixed, I just wish the response time had been quicker...
hello_william117
April 15, 2026
"Still no reply from customer service!!"
I reached out twice and still never heard anything back!! Frustrating when you’re just trying to get a simple response.
DeliaDudley
March 26, 2026
"Am I the only one who had a..."
Am I the only one who had a tough time using this site? It was frustrating for me. Pages were loading slowly, the search results felt all over the place, and I kept losing track of what I’d clicked on. Even checkout wasn’t very clear. After a while, I just gave up and bought my yarn somewhere else.
Stacy-hawk
March 24, 2026
"Tracking never actually updated"
My tracking was stuck on “label created” for days with no real scan after that. In my head, if there’s no scan, I just assume it hasn’t actually shipped, even if the order says it’s on the way. It was really frustrating not knowing whether my package was moving or just sitting somewhere. I don’t think I’d order from here again.
shawnsanchez9875
March 03, 2026
"Returns were such a hassle"
I ordered some yarn and when it showed up, the colors just weren’t what I thought they’d be. I figured I’d do a simple exchange, but the return instructions were confusing, and I ended up having to email more than once just to figure out what I was supposed to do.

by the end of it I felt mentally drained over something that should’ve been quick and easy. I still had to pay shipping, then wait around without clear updates, and it just wasn’t worth the frustration. I don’t think I’d order again because returns really shouldn’t be this annoying.
gilbertsvendsen6875
February 22, 2026
"Checkout was exactly the headache I expected"
I tried checking out a few times and it kept failing, which just confirmed what I already suspected about the site being a bit unreliable. After refreshing and re-entering my info more than once, I got tired of messing with it and gave up
josephchen7453
February 17, 2026
"Couldn't Find the Colors I Had in Mind"
I had a whole little project planned out in my head and was excited to get started, but when I went to pick out the colors I needed, they just weren’t available. I kept looking through the options hoping to find something close, but nothing really matched what I had in mind. Kind of disappointing because the colors were the main reason I was interested in the first place.
maryann2004
February 11, 2026
"Shipping cost felt really unreasonable"
I was ready to place a small yarn order from creativeyarnsource.com, but once I saw the shipping cost, I backed out. It ended up being way higher than I expected, and it made the whole order feel not worth it.
I can’t really speak to the yarn itself since I didn’t get that far, but the shipping price alone was enough to turn me off. For something like this, I’d expect the cost to be shown more clearly earlier on, or at least some kind of discount or compensation to make up for how excessive it felt
stephaniecrock2240
February 07, 2026
"Pretty close to the photos"
The yarn colors were mostly what I expected from the pictures. One skein was a little darker than the others, but I figured there might be slight differences since photos and screens can make colors look a bit different. Overall, I’m happy with it
hello_david868
February 03, 2026
"Disappointing yarn selection"
I went in hoping to find a few good yarn options, but the selection was really small and uninspiring. There was barely anything I was looking for. If a store is going to advertise yarn and craft supplies, they should do a better job keeping the section stocked and offering more variety.
hello_david942
January 27, 2026
"I was disappointed with this yarn..."
I was disappointed with this yarn. I opened it while having coffee at my kitchen table, and right away it felt kind of rough and cheap in my hands. I tried to start a little scarf with it, but it was scratchy enough that I knew I wouldn’t want it against my skin. I’m not planning to buy this one again.
nettie_Vega92
January 26, 2026
"Prices felt a bit too steep for me"
I checked out Creative Yarn Source because I was looking for some yarn, but honestly... the prices felt high to me.
I compared a few items with other shops, and I was able to find similar options for less, so it just didn’t really make sense for me to buy there.

The yarn might be great, I can’t really say... but I couldn’t get past the pricing, so I ended up ordering from somewhere else
jeff_Bough81
January 06, 2026
"Decent site, but the selection wasn’t there"
I checked the site because I’d seen a few patterns mentioned online and was hoping to grab a couple of them. The site itself looks nice and gives the impression that there’s a good range to choose from, but when I actually searched, most of what I wanted either wasn’t listed or showed as unavailable.
The search feature didn’t make things much easier either, which was frustrating. I can see the potential if they keep things better stocked and easier to find, but this time I ended up giving up and ordering from somewhere else.
EsperanzaWhitley_70
January 04, 2026
"NA"
NA
Dorothea_cherry82
December 28, 2025
"One of the colors ended up being..."
One of the colors ended up being sold out, but the rest of it shipped just fine. They got it out smoothly overall.

View More Reviews

Have a question about Creative Yarn Source?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.